The View from Sports Center

A Year Ago on The View from Sports Center

Here's what was happening last year:

• Did I Make it Through the Movie?
• Time to Play
• Mind the Crap Gap
• New Supplement for Chronic Joint Pain
• Read, Aim, Fire
• Brain Magic
• Three Words Worth Banning
• All Exercise is Not Equal
• Chapter 20: Less is More
• Chapter 19: Drugged in the Dreaded Tube

Make today count.
DK

You can comment on any post by clicking "COMMENTS" at the end of the article. Share your opinions and ideas!

**

For the latest on MY TRAINING ROUTINES, click here .

**

New to the View? Consider subscribing to my RSS feed: Subscribe to this blog's feed. Or sign up to get email updates in the box at the top left hand corner of my blog and then share this blog with your friends.

**

Do you have a copy of my new book, "The Little Book of Sparks"? You can read a sample and order it here.

Good News for Runners

You stand a better chance of living a longer and healthier life than people who don't run according to a study published last year in the Archives of Internal Medicine.

The study followed over 500 people - runners and non-runners - over a 20 year period. Although runners decreased their average amount of time per week from four hours at the start of the study to a little over an hour by the end of the study, runners had less disability and fewer early deaths from conditions such as cancer, infections, or neurologic disease.

The lead author, Professor James Fries told the BBC News, "The study has a very pro-exercise message. If you had to pick one thing to make people healthier as they age, it would be aerobic exercise. The health benefits of exercise are greater than we thought."

But, is it running that delivers the benefit or is it the aerobic nature of the activity?

Aerobic exercise is not limited to running. You can cycle, swim, or perform resistive exercise and make your heart and lungs work too. "Cardio" is no longer king. What this study shows is that people who exercise over their lifetime are generally healthier and live longer. They used running as a means to achieve those benefits.

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reports that the health benefits of exercise appear at 150 minutes per week and increase at 300 minutes per week. This is at least moderate intensity exercise . The more intense the exercise, the less total time is required to achieve the health benefits (for example, you can cut 150 minutes per week to 75 minutes if the exercise is vigorous). And remember, if you're not sweating, it's not exercise (yes, there are exceptions for the exceptionally fit, highly competitive athlete).

So, how many minutes per week are you investing for your self?

DK

You can comment on any post by clicking "COMMENTS" at the end of the article. Share your opinions and ideas!

**

For the latest on MY TRAINING ROUTINES, click here .

**

New to the View? Consider subscribing to my RSS feed: Subscribe to this blog's feed. Or sign up to get email updates in the box at the top left hand corner of my blog and then share this blog with your friends.

**

Did you know I have another blog? If you enjoy the science and art of getting and staying fit, you might enjoy Exercise:ology.

**

Do you have a copy of my new book, "The Little Book of Sparks"? You can read a sample and order it here.

Is the Core Craze the Crux of the Problem?

Reader Renee points us to an article in the NY Times about the dangers and pitfalls of "core" strengthening. It's worth reading as are the comments.

I agree with most everything in the article. The transverse abdominis, while important, is not the only muscle you need to be concerned about and that hollowing the stomach by aggressively sucking it in may do more harm than good by de-stabilizing the supporting structures. Sit-ups are a poor choice for most people carrying far more risk than necessary and that goes for back extensions over the edge of a stool or a Roman Chair too.

My disagreement in avoiding using isolating techniques to activate the transverse addominis is that the stabilizing muscles, multifidus and rotatores, are inhibited following a back injury and since these muscles are not under your volitional control, you must find another way to jump start them. The transverse abdominis is the jump start mechanism. Once you learn how to contract the transverse abdominis (and this is done not sucking in the stomach but rather bracing the mid-section as if you're about to get punched in the stomach), which by the way needs only a mild contraction to turn on the multifidus, you can then move on to more functional drills incorporating the tension from the transverse abdominis.

Of course, there's no strong link between a "weak core" and lower back pain but there is evidence that suggests people with chronic lower back pain tend to have an atrophied multifidus muscle and we know that atrophied muscles are weak muscles.

Hides, J. A., C. A. Richardson, et al. (1996). "Multifidus muscle recovery is not automatic after resolution of acute, first-episode low back pain." Spine 21(23): 2763-9.
Danneels, L. A., G. G. Vanderstraeten, et al. (2000). "CT imaging of trunk muscles in chronic low back pain patients and healthy control subjects." European Spine Journal 9(4): 266-72.

Question from a Reader: PRP Not Covered by Insurance?

Hi,
I have knee cartilage problems & would love to try PRP. However, my insurance will not pay for such therapy & I cannot afford the $2,500 it will likely cost me for a self-pay treatment. I imagine the cost is an obstacle for many people with joint & tendon problems who would like to try this. Do you have any suggestions on how I might obtain a reduced rate from the provider? Do you have a sense of when insurance might cover this? Thanks!

Neil

---

Hi Neil,

Thanks for your questions. I know other people are in a similar situation.  I have some thoughts for you about your knee and, as a disclaimer, I make them only to offer you another way of looking at your situation. I'm trying to help.

I'm going to push you a little on your statement that you can't afford the fee (and I think the cost is closer to $1000 to $1500). When it comes to healthcare, one of the first things people often say is, "My insurance won't pay so I can't afford it." This perspective seems independent of one's actual purchasing power. One of the side effects of health insurance is a subconscious sense of entitlement which is completely understandable. You've paid for coverage and you expect to have a benefit. But, health insurance is merely a contract that agrees to provide you specific benefits to assist you in paying for healthcare services. It does not replace an individual's own responsibility to take care of themselves.

Here are some things to consider to help you pay for healthcare services like a PRP injection.

• Analyze your "Latte money". My wife and I call frequent, seemingly low cost expenditures "Latte money". It's the money you would spend if you went to Starbucks everyday and bought a Latte for $3 or $4. Over a month that's about $80. In one year that's nearly $1000. If you find your "Latte money" and cut it out of your spending, you could very likely pay for a PRP injection.
• Call the provider and ask if they have any payment plans. Most do.
• Pay your self first. Out of your paycheck, transfer a small amount of money into a savings account. This works best if it is transferred before you get the check. If you could save even as little as $50/month, in ten months, you would have enough money that you could at least get the injection and if the provider has a payment plan, pay off the remaining balance in another ten months.
• Get a loan. While I'm not a fan of consumer debt (like buying a 65"plasma TV and paying it off for 48 months), we're talking about your body and your quality of life. Good health is the source of all personal freedom. It is truly priceless. If you have to borrow the money to get healthy, it will likely be worth every penny. Interestingly, many people will not think twice about spending $3000 on a 65" TV but shudder at spending that same amount on their health.

As for getting providers to reduce their fees, you certainly can ask. Most won't reduce their fees on these types of procedures because they take such huge reductions on the procedures that are covered by insurance. For example, a urologist I know of recently decided to stop performing kidney transplants and instead has decided to perform more vasectomies. Why? He was paid $500 to perform a kidney transplant and $1500 to perform a vasectomy. Kidney transplants are more work not only in terms of the surgery but the follow up care and carry more risk for both patient and surgeon. Boggles my mind. He's paid more to prevent life from starting that to prevent a life from ending.

Insurance comes late to the game on things like PRP. It's relatively new so until there is enough proof that the procedure will reduce the need for more expensive procedures and longer term care, insurance will sit on the sidelines. I have no idea when or if any companies will cover it.

Finally, PRP is not a panacea. You still need to go through a rehabilitative process which, if you have not tried this already, may help you. You may find, with the correct program, that many of your symptoms will subside. Managing a knee problem is a lifestyle shift. You have to not only do the right exercises, you also have to find the positions and activities in your daily life that overload your knee and remove them or alter them until your knee is healthy enough to tolerate those activities.

DK

You can comment on any post by clicking "COMMENTS" at the end of the article. Share your opinions and ideas!

**

For the latest on MY TRAINING ROUTINES, click here .

**

New to the View? Consider subscribing to my RSS feed: Subscribe to this blog's feed. Or sign up to get email updates in the box at the top left hand corner of my blog and then share this blog with your friends.

**

Did you know I have another blog? If you enjoy the science and art of getting and staying fit, you might enjoy Exercise:ology.

**

Do you have a copy of my new book, "The Little Book of Sparks"? You can read a sample and order it here.

Back Pain and Giving Up

Eighty percent of people will have low back pain in their lifetime bad enough to seek medical care. For some, the symptoms fade within six or eight weeks. But, for over half, the pain returns within one year and often becomes a most unwelcome and rather permanent house guest.

And, what type of care do people get? To find out, a group of researchers in North Carolina contacted 5,357 households and found 732 adults with chronic low back pain*. Of the 732 people, 590 had sought medical care. Here's what else they found:

• 31% had taken a muscle relaxant in the last 30 days.
• 60% had taken a narcotic in the last 30 days.
• Greater than 33% had some form of imaging study done (MRI, CT SCAN) in the past year.
• Less than 30% had seen a physical therapist.
• 3% had been in a spine rehabilitation program.
• Levels of depression were high.

Depression is a common finding in people with chronic back pain and is compounded by a feeling of hopelessness about the situation. Chronic back pain carries a very high emotional tax (and, yes, all pain has an emotional tax but back pain seems to be one of the worst types. Nearly, 54% of people are depressed prior to the onset of their pain.). You worry. You wonder if you'll ever feel better or do the things you once loved to do or even come close. Day after day you get caught in a vortex of anxiety and discouragement. Life is grey.

The passive nature of treatment - drugs - for so many people with lower back pain can unintentionally add to the weight of hopelessness. Sometimes the drugs are helpful and needed to get people moving but as this study shows, few of them ever land in a program designed to help get them moving in the right direction. Instead, they take medication and hope until their hope is so thin and frail it cracks. Some fill the cracks with despair; some bitterness; others use resentment. The fix is as fragile as the crack itself.

What do you do? If you like your doctor and trust him or her, ask for a referral. Tell him you need to see someone who can help you get moving again. Some physical therapists and chiropractors and massage therapists focus their work on movement. Other practitioners who can help are trained in Feldenkrais Method or Alexander Technique. Yoga and Pilates can also be quite effective in the hands of a skilled teacher. If you can't get a referral and your state (or your insurance) requires one, switch doctors. Friends, family, colleagues may also be able to suggest someone that can help you.

Just don't quit. Fight. After all, what's the outcome of giving up?

DK

*Carey, T. S., J. K. Freburger, et al. (2009). "A Long Way to Go: Practice Patterns and Evidence in Chronic Low Back Pain Care." Spine 34(7): 718-724

---

You can comment on any post by clicking "COMMENTS" at the end of the article. Share your opinions and ideas!

**

For the latest on MY TRAINING ROUTINES, click here .

**

New to the View? Consider subscribing to my RSS feed: Subscribe to this blog's feed. Or sign up to get email updates in the box at the top left hand corner of my blog and then share this blog with your friends.

**

Did you know I have another blog? If you enjoy the science and art of getting and staying fit, you might enjoy Exercise:ology.

**

Do you have a copy of my new book, "The Little Book of Sparks"? You can read a sample and order it here.